As a person who used to have a cat (sadly she passed away), I wouldn't lose interest in a man who mentionss missing his pet.
It would actually give him a brownie point with me,for caring about animals.
I think the thing that was so goofy is that it was a cold Friday night, he's sitting by the fire with a drink and he was (presumably) flirting with a pretty woman and he misses his dog? He has a dog, btw. I think ppl here are right - he was trying to make a joke and it fell flat.
Didn't miss an episode!!