This is where I'm calling major bs Whikle. I hate when girls feel the need to defend every big chick in the interest of dispelling the skinny girl beauty myth. Why does it always have to be either a 100 lbs girl or a 300 lbs girl (which Gabby clearly is) you mean to tell me there aren't any non skinny girls who are 160 to 200 lbs who don't look like a fucking balloon with feet? Its total horseshit. I definitely see what smooth is talking about.
I'm sorry, Andrae, I just can't agree with you on this. The two of us are coming at it from entirely different angles.
Gabby weighing 300-400 pounds or however much is not the point. It's not about her being unusually large. The same argument would apply if she were 250 pounds, 200 pounds, 160 pounds... The fact is, she has the right to be promoted positively.
Every time a bigger woman is in the spotlight she is HOUNDED by people who think she's "disgusting" or "unhealthy", and "how DARE they assault our eyes with something so offensive?"... And that's just so unfair and so unhealthy for women's self esteem. It's not about 300 pound women sitting at home being able to feel validated, it's about women everywhere with all types of bodies at all types of weight feeling that it's ok to be who you are, you don't have to look like a supermodel to be accepted by society. You don't have to look like Gabby either, and hey, most women don't. But women are CONSTANTLY bombarded with unrealistic images of beauty. You, as a man, have absolutely zero concept of how that feels for a woman. So frankly, you don't have much right to comment on it, IMO.
And here's why its offensive. Gabby is the embodiment of what they're trying to sell as black beauty? Do you have any clue how insulting that is? All of her supporters are the lazy ass people who refuse to take care of themselves and white people who have little to no contact with bw and are uncomfortable around them so they'll cosign any bullshit.
Now, I can't talk about Gabby being promoted as "black beauty". I don't live in the states, I don't get that angle on it. But how about Gabby as being presented as "another kind" of beauty. Because she actually is beautiful. And "beauty" HAS to stop being defined as fitting within one little narrow scope of what we see in magazines and on television daily.
Like I said, I don't think it's right to have one example of larger women out there and then the media can brush its' hands and say "ok, we've done our part to promote positive self image, we're done here" and feel good about themselves. We need to have more beautiful women of all shapes and sizes used in all aspects of the media as "the norm". To me, having a woman like Gabby promoted positively is just a step in the right direction, not the holy grail.
And, by the way, I would defend this position just as fiercely if I weighed 120 pounds myself. It's not personal, it's about acceptance and reality.
And here's a newsflash fat men aren't celebrated either. You won't catch fat person of any gender or race in peoples top 50 beautiful people because its not ideal. Our ideas of beauty as humans in terms of the physical come down to the ideal that we want look like ourselves or would like to fuck period the end. Very few people would consider someone fat as their ideal unless there was a weird pyschological component.
And THIS... well, this is just ignorance. You have no idea how socially constructed "beauty" is, do you? You have no concept of how much what you find attractive is actually dictated by what is drummed into you by the media and by society as acceptable. Beauty is just like fashion. There will always be those who march to the beat of their own drum, but for the most part we are all blind sheep who will follow the norm.
Different ages, different cultures, different countries have seen a huge variety of bodies being considered the most sexually appealing. We happen to live in a day and age and society that values slender bodies.
Trust me, if women with bodies like mine were promoted in the media the way skinny models and actresses were, I would be the ultimate in sex appeal to the majority of men. Sure, there'd still be those who are attracted to skinnier girls, but they'd be more of a minority like those who are into big girls now. And many women would strive to have bodies like mine because that's what's seen as ultimate beauty.
If you think we as socialised human beings have much control over what we think we "like", you'd be mistaken.