Is This Ad Racist?

The Dark King said:
As the only Jamaican on here I will say its not racist since Jamaica has people ranging from those of African descent to Chinese and European descent but that shit was a little culturally insensitive. I know its just a commercial but how would you guys feel if the ad was a white person talking the way they thought people from "the hood" spoke. It comes across as a little annoying right? Or Aussie from the outback with everything being about damn shrimps on the barbie? There's a lot more to the culture than that right?
And the happy go lucky everything is gonna be alright Jamaican man is a fucking myth outside of the resorts. Walk around Spanish town or even certain parts of Montego Bay and when you see all the devastating poverty you'll see how bullshit that whole thing is. Like any other people Jamaicans are forced to make lemons out of lemonade but the whole slightly high dreaded overtly friendly image can be annoying to the people. I guess that's why they did this, to get people talking. They wouldn't have pulled it off if Bob was another stereotypical happy go lucky type from the midwest.
Click to expand...

As another Jamaican here, I disagree to a certain extent. It may be a little stereotypical(besides aren't stereotypes often based on truth?), but it shows Jamaicans in a more positive light. I mean I'm only speaking for myself and not any other Jamaicans, but I liked it and I wasn't offended or annoyed by the guy's upbeat and positive out look on life. Isn't that a good thing? Of course Jamaica is like anywhere else. You have your positive people and your negative people. A matter of fact, I need to be more like that guy myself. I'm more of the negative, cynical, pessimestic, half glass empty, kind of person myself. lol
 
The commercial is awkward pushing right up to the line of cultural insensitivity. Doesn't mean it's racist, just like a White friend inviting you to a weekend lunch buffet of fried chicken and watermelon fruit salad isn't racist either...but.

It would have worked better IMO if it had been maybe a white woman talking in that accent.

The message I guess overrides the insensitivity, but like others have said if he'd been talking in stereotypical Black American ebonics but with a 'positive' message, they never would have played the commercial.
 
Last edited:
andreboba said:
The commercial is awkward pushing right up to the line of cultural insensitivity. Doesn't mean it's racist, just like a White friend inviting you to a weekend lunch buffet of fried chicken and watermelon fruit salad isn't racist either...but.

I'd would have worked better IMO if it had been maybe a white woman talking in that accent.

The message I guess overrides the insensitivity, but like others have said if he'd been talking in stereotypical Black American ebonics but with a 'positive' message, they never would have played the commercial.
Click to expand...

uh_wtf_gif.gif
 
i don't know how ppl could like this.......they even calling this complimentary and as a positive? shaking my head at the coonery. rg3 worthy.....
 
TERRASTAR18 said:
i don't know how ppl could like this.......they even calling this complimentary and as a positive? shaking my head at the coonery. rg3 worthy.....
Click to expand...

speaking and writing the white man's language makes you just as much of a coon as anyone else, genius

why dont you go learn some swahili and keep it real, brotha

smiling_african_man.jpg
 
andreboba said:
The commercial is awkward pushing right up to the line of cultural insensitivity. Doesn't mean it's racist, just like a White friend inviting you to a weekend lunch buffet of fried chicken and watermelon fruit salad isn't racist either...but.

I'd would have worked better IMO if it had been maybe a white woman talking in that accent.

The message I guess overrides the insensitivity, but like others have said if he'd been talking in stereotypical Black American ebonics but with a 'positive' message, they never would have played the commercial.
Click to expand...

Well said
+1
 
Oh please! This is like the Fosters How to speak australian ad's..in the scheme of things they are just silly ads :rolleyes:

Even Jimmy Cliff is in on the silliness...He makes fun of cat ladies...that VW make fun of...its all just SB commercial craziness...lighten up, jezuss! :smt101


[YOUTUBE]NfCm9P8naDQ[/YOUTUBE]
 
Bliss said:
Oh please! This is like the Fosters How to speak australian ad's..in the scheme of things they are just silly ads :rolleyes:

Even Jimmy Cliff is in on the silliness...He makes fun of cat ladies...that VW make fun of...its all just SB commercial craziness...lighten up, jezuss! :smt101


[YOUTUBE]NfCm9P8naDQ[/YOUTUBE]
Click to expand...

Easy to say when you're not part of a group that's constantly marginalized. Again not saying its racist just a little culturally insensitive.
 
Bliss said:
Are Jamaicans constantly marginalized?
Click to expand...

In the way they are crammed in a monolithic stereotype of weed smoking everything is gonna be alright caricatures yeah. I'm not saying its the most offensive thing in the world but in response to the OP's question I do find this mildly offensive. Like I said if it were the same guy speaking like he was from the "hood" it would be a different conversation.
 
The Dark King said:
In the way they are crammed in a monolithic stereotype of weed smoking everything is gonna be alright caricatures yeah. I'm not saying its the most offensive thing in the world but in response to the OP's question I do find this mildly offensive. Like I said if it were the same guy speaking like he was from the "hood" it would be a different conversation.
Click to expand...

What about the stereotype that they are hard workers, great cooks? Must you find negativity in everything? Even something conveying a message to be happy?This isn't an ad of them smoking...
it's playing on Jimmy Cliff's very famous 'C'mon, Get Happy song.

Furthermore VW market-tested this ad to over 100 Jamaicans who loved it.

But I will take the Ad in the spirit it was delivered. Seems that Jamaica’s Minister of Tourism and Entertainment Wykeham McNeill agrees...he issued a statement supporting the ad as: “a tribute to reggae’s popularity worldwide”. He saluted Cliff for being “a true Jamaican ambassador” and urged people everywhere to “do exactly what the commercial portrays, tap into your inner Jamaican and get happy.” :freehug:
 
Bliss said:
What about the stereotype that they are hard workers, great cooks? Must you find negativity in everything? Even something conveying a message to be happy?This isn't an ad of them smoking...
it's playing on Jimmy Cliff's very famous 'C'mon, Get Happy song.

Furthermore VW market-tested this ad to over 100 Jamaicans who loved it.

But I will take the Ad in the spirit it was delivered. Seems that Jamaica’s Minister of Tourism and Entertainment Wykeham McNeill agrees...he issued a statement supporting the ad as: “a tribute to reggae’s popularity worldwide”. He saluted Cliff for being “a true Jamaican ambassador” and urged people everywhere to “do exactly what the commercial portrays, tap into your inner Jamaican and get happy.” :freehug:
Click to expand...

Holy shit am I not entitled to my own opinion. I see differently. So what?
 
Look, Athenos had fun with the revered and respected Greek grandmother by playing off of a stereotype about them...:smt036

She calls them porn-actors-

[YOUTUBE]ZuyCW8pDdao[/YOUTUBE]

She insults, calling DIL a hooker-

[YOUTUBE]dcD6JaEArPc[/YOUTUBE]

Insults, calling a wife a sick pervert-

[YOUTUBE]mFSKqkDiSJY[/YOUTUBE]

Insults a stay-at home dad-

[YOUTUBE]9wLeuVoWUkk[/YOUTUBE]

No one got hot-and-bothered or complained. Greeks laughed their asses off. :smt043
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom